So without further ado, here is the unboxing that I filmed! Thanks very much to D. E. Night and her publicist for sending this my way :)
I'm no longer practically the last person on Earth to have not read this
book! This is one of those books that I think is objectively quite
well-written, but I just didn't emotionally connect with, personally.
(No, it did not make me cry.) Hazel was a likeable protagonist who felt
human and distinctive, and since she is the narrator we get to know her
the best; yet even so, I still didn't feel as close to her as I would
have liked.
This
contemporary YA novel has gotten quite a bit of hype and I know a lot
of people loved it, but unfortunately I didn't fall head-over-heels for
it. I mostly liked the main character Samantha, whose voice was
relatable and felt realistic as a teen's. Jase, on the other hand, while
sweet and rather mature for a teenage guy, seemed a little too perfect;
he never made mistakes and always appeared to know best, and it came
off as a bit holier-than-thou at times (especially when all the other
teens were making mistakes left, right, and center). I did enjoy the
general dynamic of the Garrett family and the contrast to Samantha's,
and found it interesting how entrenched she becomes in their life, which
is unusual to see in a YA novel.
The Song Rising by Samantha Shannon
So, that was intense. The second half of the book really amped up the stakes and I felt like I was right there with Paige. I was a little disappointed with the lack of development of the Paige/Warden relationship (and that Warden didn't get a larger role, because I love his character). It seemed like they were getting emotionally separated to increase the drama more than because it would have naturally stemmed from the characters themselves (although Paige is, admittedly, rather closed-off, so it wasn't a huge stretch). (Why can those two not just TALK everything out??)
This book feels more like a "stepping stone" book than the previous ones have. A lot of the first half was chasing information down and rehashing conversations; however, things really picked up in the second half. I liked how Paige ended up playing such a pivotal role in the climax. There was also a reveal there that I definitely did not see coming.
Also, I enjoyed getting to see voyant communities outside of London, and it looks like we'll get to see some more of that in the next book! I think I didn't like this book quite as much as the previous two but I'm still looking forward to seeing what happens next.